Preparing resources...
Preparing resources...
Preparing resources...
A complete, evidence-based breakdown of energy drinks and pre-workout supplements for adolescent and young adult athletes — what's safe, what's dangerous, how to talk about it, and what your team policy should say.
Your athletes are already having the conversation. They're talking in the weight room about which pre-workout hits hardest, sending TikToks about the new energy drink flavor, and passing around cans before early morning practice. The question isn't whether your athletes are consuming these products — it's whether you're equipped to talk about them productively.
This is not a "just say no" article. That approach doesn't work with teenagers, it doesn't align with the actual evidence, and it ignores the fact that some of these substances — when used appropriately — do have legitimate performance applications. What follows is an evidence-based framework for understanding what's in these products, what the real risks are, and how to have the conversation without losing your athletes' trust.
Let's start with caffeine because it's doing the vast majority of the work in almost every energy drink, pre-workout, and "focus" supplement on the market.
Caffeine is a methylxanthine that works by blocking adenosine receptors in the brain. Adenosine is the compound that accumulates over the course of a day and makes you feel progressively more fatigued. Block the receptor and the fatigue signal doesn't reach its destination. You don't get more energy — you get diminished perception of tiredness, along with some stimulant effects on the central nervous system.
Performance-wise, caffeine is one of the most well-supported ergogenic aids in sports science. It demonstrably improves endurance performance, reduces perceived exertion, and can improve power output and sprint performance with appropriate dosing.
The adolescent safety question is where it gets complicated. The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) reviewed the evidence and concluded that 3 mg per kilogram of body weight per day is the safe upper limit for adolescents. This is the standard most sports medicine organizations have adopted.
What does that mean in practice? A 130-pound (59 kg) athlete's safe daily ceiling is approximately 177 mg of caffeine. Now look at what's actually in the products they're using:
One can of Celsius gets a 130-pound athlete to 113% of their daily safe limit before they've had breakfast coffee or any other caffeine-containing food. And these are the products being sold in convenience stores next to your school.
The Sleep Architecture Problem: Even if an athlete stays under the 3 mg/kg threshold, caffeine has a half-life of 5-7 hours. A 200mg Celsius drank at an after-school track practice (3:30 PM) still leaves roughly 100mg of caffeine active in the brain at 10 PM. This destroys the deep delta-wave sleep architecture required for musculoskeletal recovery and HGH (human growth hormone) release.
Caffeine is the star, but most energy drinks bundle in several other ingredients. Here's what's actually doing what:
Sugar: Most traditional energy drinks contain 26–54 grams of sugar per serving. This provides real, short-term energy — but it's followed by an insulin response, and many of the "enhanced performance" effects people attribute to the drink are just the acute effects of rapid carbohydrate availability.
B vitamins (B6, B12, niacin): Every energy drink is loaded with them. The marketing implies they're energy-producing. The reality is that B vitamins support metabolic processes, but supplementing beyond what's needed for deficiency correction does nothing for performance. These are essentially marketing ingredients — benign, but not performance-relevant.
Taurine: An amino acid that's often listed prominently. It plays roles in cardiac function and antioxidant activity. At the doses in energy drinks (typically 1,000 mg), it appears to be safe, and there's preliminary evidence for modest cardiovascular and performance benefits. Not dangerous, not impressive.
Guarana: A plant extract that contains caffeine — typically more caffeine per gram than coffee beans. When a product lists "guarana extract" in addition to listed caffeine, the listed caffeine dose underestimates total caffeine intake. This is the hidden source of excess caffeine.
"Proprietary blends": When you see this on a label, it means the manufacturer is not required to disclose individual ingredient doses — only the total blend weight. Proprietary blends warrant extra caution.
Energy drinks are regulated as beverages under FDA oversight. Pre-workout supplements fall under the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA), which means they receive substantially less regulatory scrutiny.
Beta-alanine: The ingredient that causes the "tingle" sensation (paresthesia). It's a precursor to carnosine, which buffers acid in muscle during high-intensity exercise. The performance evidence is actually decent for events lasting 1–4 minutes — a range that includes 400m through 1500m. The tingling is harmless but can be anxiety-provoking.
Citrulline: An amino acid that increases blood arginine levels, which supports nitric oxide production and vasodilation. There's modest evidence for improved blood flow and reduced fatigue in endurance activities. Appears to be safe; limited long-term data in adolescents.
DMAA (1,3-dimethylamylamine): This is where the conversation gets serious. DMAA is a synthetic stimulant that the FDA has explicitly warned is not a legitimate dietary ingredient. It's linked to documented adverse cardiac events, hemorrhagic stroke, and deaths — including in otherwise healthy young adults. This is not a risk-benefit calculation; it's a flat no.
DMHA, eria jarensis, synephrine: A family of stimulants that operate similarly to DMAA. Treat them the same way.
The cardiac risk associated with energy drinks in adolescents is documented in the peer-reviewed literature. The American Academy of Pediatrics published a clinical report documenting adverse events including seizures, stroke, renal failure, and sudden cardiac death in children and adolescents following energy drink consumption.
The mechanism is multifactorial: high caffeine doses increase heart rate and blood pressure; taurine and other compounds affect ion channels in cardiac cells; in athletes with undiagnosed structural heart abnormalities (hypertrophic cardiomyopathy being the most concerning), stimulant loads can be the trigger for arrhythmia.
Lead with curiosity, not judgment. "I know a lot of you are using pre-workout or energy drinks before training. I'm curious — do you know what's actually in them?"
Use the pharmacology. Teenagers are surprisingly interested in how things actually work.
Acknowledge what the evidence supports. Caffeine at appropriate doses does improve performance. Don't pretend otherwise.
Separate product categories. "I'm not telling you caffeine is dangerous — I'm telling you that this specific product has an ingredient the FDA has flagged for cardiac events."
Involve parents. A parent communication that covers the basics — not panic-inducing, just informative — is worth doing once a year.
[Team Name] recognizes that student athletes may encounter marketing for energy drinks and pre-workout supplements. Our team policy is as follows:
No energy drinks or pre-workout supplements are to be consumed at team practices, competitions, or team-sponsored events. This includes products containing caffeine blends, proprietary stimulant blends, or ingredients not approved as safe for adolescent use by the FDA.
Caffeinated beverages (coffee, tea) are not prohibited but are discouraged within two hours of competition due to potential GI effects and anxiety.
Athletes with questions about specific supplements are encouraged to speak with the coaching staff. Any supplement use should be disclosed to the coaching staff and should involve a parent/guardian.
Sleep: Losing even 90 minutes of sleep the night before competition can reduce performance by an amount comparable to being legally intoxicated. No supplement compensates for this.
Carbohydrate timing: A banana, a handful of crackers, or a sports drink 30–45 minutes before training accomplishes the same "energy" effect — without the caffeine load.
Hydration: Even 2% dehydration measurably impairs cognitive performance and perceived exertion.
Strategic caffeine use: For competition days, a small dose of caffeine from a known source (coffee) at an appropriate dose for the athlete's body weight, taken 30–45 minutes before competition, is evidence-supported.
| Feature | Energy Drink (typical) | Sports Drink | Water |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary function | Stimulant/alertness | Fuel + hydration | Hydration |
| Caffeine | 80–300 mg | 0 mg | 0 mg |
| Sugar | 0–54g | 14–34g | 0g |
| Electrolytes | Minimal | Yes (Na, K) | No |
| Best use case | None during training | During/after exercise | Before/during/after |
| Hydrates effectively | Poorly (diuretic effect) | Yes | Yes |
| Safe for adolescents | With caveats | Yes | Yes |
| Cost per serving | $2–$4 | $1–$2 | Negligible |
| Risk of overconsumption | Moderate–High | Low | None |
| Evidence for performance | Limited (caffeine only) | Yes (for 60+ min exercise) | Foundational |
This week, run a 5-minute team education block:
The goal is clarity, not fear.
Bottom Line Caffeine is not automatically the problem; unregulated stimulant products are. A clear team policy, label literacy, and practical alternatives protect athlete health without losing trust.
A complete, evidence-based breakdown of energy drinks and pre-workout supplements for adolescent and young adult athletes — what's safe, what's dangerous, how to talk about it, and what your team policy should say.
Your athletes are already having the conversation. They're talking in the weight room about which pre-workout hits hardest, sending TikToks about the new energy drink flavor, and passing around cans before early morning practice. The question isn't whether your athletes are consuming these products — it's whether you're equipped to talk about them productively.
This is not a "just say no" article. That approach doesn't work with teenagers, it doesn't align with the actual evidence, and it ignores the fact that some of these substances — when used appropriately — do have legitimate performance applications. What follows is an evidence-based framework for understanding what's in these products, what the real risks are, and how to have the conversation without losing your athletes' trust.
Let's start with caffeine because it's doing the vast majority of the work in almost every energy drink, pre-workout, and "focus" supplement on the market.
Caffeine is a methylxanthine that works by blocking adenosine receptors in the brain. Adenosine is the compound that accumulates over the course of a day and makes you feel progressively more fatigued. Block the receptor and the fatigue signal doesn't reach its destination. You don't get more energy — you get diminished perception of tiredness, along with some stimulant effects on the central nervous system.
Performance-wise, caffeine is one of the most well-supported ergogenic aids in sports science. It demonstrably improves endurance performance, reduces perceived exertion, and can improve power output and sprint performance with appropriate dosing.
The adolescent safety question is where it gets complicated. The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) reviewed the evidence and concluded that 3 mg per kilogram of body weight per day is the safe upper limit for adolescents. This is the standard most sports medicine organizations have adopted.
What does that mean in practice? A 130-pound (59 kg) athlete's safe daily ceiling is approximately 177 mg of caffeine. Now look at what's actually in the products they're using:
One can of Celsius gets a 130-pound athlete to 113% of their daily safe limit before they've had breakfast coffee or any other caffeine-containing food. And these are the products being sold in convenience stores next to your school.
The Sleep Architecture Problem: Even if an athlete stays under the 3 mg/kg threshold, caffeine has a half-life of 5-7 hours. A 200mg Celsius drank at an after-school track practice (3:30 PM) still leaves roughly 100mg of caffeine active in the brain at 10 PM. This destroys the deep delta-wave sleep architecture required for musculoskeletal recovery and HGH (human growth hormone) release.
Caffeine is the star, but most energy drinks bundle in several other ingredients. Here's what's actually doing what:
Sugar: Most traditional energy drinks contain 26–54 grams of sugar per serving. This provides real, short-term energy — but it's followed by an insulin response, and many of the "enhanced performance" effects people attribute to the drink are just the acute effects of rapid carbohydrate availability.
B vitamins (B6, B12, niacin): Every energy drink is loaded with them. The marketing implies they're energy-producing. The reality is that B vitamins support metabolic processes, but supplementing beyond what's needed for deficiency correction does nothing for performance. These are essentially marketing ingredients — benign, but not performance-relevant.
Taurine: An amino acid that's often listed prominently. It plays roles in cardiac function and antioxidant activity. At the doses in energy drinks (typically 1,000 mg), it appears to be safe, and there's preliminary evidence for modest cardiovascular and performance benefits. Not dangerous, not impressive.
Guarana: A plant extract that contains caffeine — typically more caffeine per gram than coffee beans. When a product lists "guarana extract" in addition to listed caffeine, the listed caffeine dose underestimates total caffeine intake. This is the hidden source of excess caffeine.
"Proprietary blends": When you see this on a label, it means the manufacturer is not required to disclose individual ingredient doses — only the total blend weight. Proprietary blends warrant extra caution.
Energy drinks are regulated as beverages under FDA oversight. Pre-workout supplements fall under the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA), which means they receive substantially less regulatory scrutiny.
Beta-alanine: The ingredient that causes the "tingle" sensation (paresthesia). It's a precursor to carnosine, which buffers acid in muscle during high-intensity exercise. The performance evidence is actually decent for events lasting 1–4 minutes — a range that includes 400m through 1500m. The tingling is harmless but can be anxiety-provoking.
Citrulline: An amino acid that increases blood arginine levels, which supports nitric oxide production and vasodilation. There's modest evidence for improved blood flow and reduced fatigue in endurance activities. Appears to be safe; limited long-term data in adolescents.
DMAA (1,3-dimethylamylamine): This is where the conversation gets serious. DMAA is a synthetic stimulant that the FDA has explicitly warned is not a legitimate dietary ingredient. It's linked to documented adverse cardiac events, hemorrhagic stroke, and deaths — including in otherwise healthy young adults. This is not a risk-benefit calculation; it's a flat no.
DMHA, eria jarensis, synephrine: A family of stimulants that operate similarly to DMAA. Treat them the same way.
The cardiac risk associated with energy drinks in adolescents is documented in the peer-reviewed literature. The American Academy of Pediatrics published a clinical report documenting adverse events including seizures, stroke, renal failure, and sudden cardiac death in children and adolescents following energy drink consumption.
The mechanism is multifactorial: high caffeine doses increase heart rate and blood pressure; taurine and other compounds affect ion channels in cardiac cells; in athletes with undiagnosed structural heart abnormalities (hypertrophic cardiomyopathy being the most concerning), stimulant loads can be the trigger for arrhythmia.
Lead with curiosity, not judgment. "I know a lot of you are using pre-workout or energy drinks before training. I'm curious — do you know what's actually in them?"
Use the pharmacology. Teenagers are surprisingly interested in how things actually work.
Acknowledge what the evidence supports. Caffeine at appropriate doses does improve performance. Don't pretend otherwise.
Separate product categories. "I'm not telling you caffeine is dangerous — I'm telling you that this specific product has an ingredient the FDA has flagged for cardiac events."
Involve parents. A parent communication that covers the basics — not panic-inducing, just informative — is worth doing once a year.
[Team Name] recognizes that student athletes may encounter marketing for energy drinks and pre-workout supplements. Our team policy is as follows:
No energy drinks or pre-workout supplements are to be consumed at team practices, competitions, or team-sponsored events. This includes products containing caffeine blends, proprietary stimulant blends, or ingredients not approved as safe for adolescent use by the FDA.
Caffeinated beverages (coffee, tea) are not prohibited but are discouraged within two hours of competition due to potential GI effects and anxiety.
Athletes with questions about specific supplements are encouraged to speak with the coaching staff. Any supplement use should be disclosed to the coaching staff and should involve a parent/guardian.
Sleep: Losing even 90 minutes of sleep the night before competition can reduce performance by an amount comparable to being legally intoxicated. No supplement compensates for this.
Carbohydrate timing: A banana, a handful of crackers, or a sports drink 30–45 minutes before training accomplishes the same "energy" effect — without the caffeine load.
Hydration: Even 2% dehydration measurably impairs cognitive performance and perceived exertion.
Strategic caffeine use: For competition days, a small dose of caffeine from a known source (coffee) at an appropriate dose for the athlete's body weight, taken 30–45 minutes before competition, is evidence-supported.
| Feature | Energy Drink (typical) | Sports Drink | Water |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary function | Stimulant/alertness | Fuel + hydration | Hydration |
| Caffeine | 80–300 mg | 0 mg | 0 mg |
| Sugar | 0–54g | 14–34g | 0g |
| Electrolytes | Minimal | Yes (Na, K) | No |
| Best use case | None during training | During/after exercise | Before/during/after |
| Hydrates effectively | Poorly (diuretic effect) | Yes | Yes |
| Safe for adolescents | With caveats | Yes | Yes |
| Cost per serving | $2–$4 | $1–$2 | Negligible |
| Risk of overconsumption | Moderate–High | Low | None |
| Evidence for performance | Limited (caffeine only) | Yes (for 60+ min exercise) | Foundational |
This week, run a 5-minute team education block:
The goal is clarity, not fear.
Bottom Line Caffeine is not automatically the problem; unregulated stimulant products are. A clear team policy, label literacy, and practical alternatives protect athlete health without losing trust.
Open access guide
No account needed for free guides
Open access guide
No account needed for free guides